We don’t know much about the consequences of respectfulness: what happens when you treat people more respectfully? Do small acts of respectfulness generate other positive changes, such as greater participation, altruism, self-efficacy, or wellbeing? Dignity is surely entangled with other concepts, such as empowerment. But we don’t know how, just yet, or what respectfulness means to people. This quick ‘Off The Record’ study is a first step on that road.
Our study design
We invited 2,000 respondents from Kibera to the Busara Lab by text message, a day before the sessions. Participants were randomly put into one of three groups:
Control: they received the default invite message
Treatment 1: they received a message recognising them by name
Treatment 2: they received a message that included both their name and a choice of attendance time
We sought to answer the following questions:
Do more people show up? Whether they attended the lab or not was our first outcome measure.
Are they more altruistic? For the 239 people who attended the lab session, we reinforced their treatment by reminding them of the messages they had received. Then we looked at whether this increased altruism (in a Dictator game).
Are they more empowered? This was measured via the proxy of self-efficacy.
Are they happier? This was measured via the proxy of wellbeing.
What we learned
It turned out that small acts of respectfulness – giving choices over time and using names – did not affect participation, altruism, self-efficacy, or wellbeing. As evidenced in this graph, being recognised by name or given a choice of what time to attend did not make people significantly more likely to show up than those in the control group. It did not make them significantly more altruistic, bring them higher self-efficacy or higher wellbeing.
What should we conclude? Here are some possibilities. First of all, maybe we’re underpowered. Second, respectfulness is more radical than just politeness – perhaps small acts of respectfulness aren’t enough. Third, respectfulness is always intertwined with expectations. When people expect to be treated well, higher dose treatments are needed. And fourth, respectfulness is important in its own right. We don’t need to see positive effects in other domains for this to be important.